A solution for Santa Teresa while we wait for the Bondinho
Anyone who has visited Rio’s Santa Teresa neighbourhood over the last 3 years may have been a little confused. The picturesque streets that trace the area’s steep hills and hairpin bends are covered in tracks, yet the Santa Teresa tram has not been seen here since August 2011. Instead you see posters on walls and stickers in car windows showing the image above.
Back when I first moved to Rio, the tram of Santa Teresa, better known as the Bonde or Bondinho, was a major tourist attraction. The bright yellow wooden tram cars were rickety but pretty and made for an utterly charming way to get around Santa Teresa. However, although tourists and locals flocked to the trams, all was not well.
The tram cars were ancient. Sometime around 2006-07, a company named T-Trans was contracted to restore 14 tram cars but what they eventually delivered became known as ‘Frankensteins’ – a mish-mash of old and new parts with a price tag of more than a million Reais (compared with R$300,000 to restore the original cars).
One of the major problem points was with the brakes – these were mounted externally which meant that they were vulnerable to damage in the event of a collision. Despite warnings, this is exactly what happened in 2009 when a taxi collided with a tram, causing the brakes to fail and leading to the death of a teacher from Paraty. Only 7 of the 14 trams were delivered and lots of money from the project went unaccounted for.
The trains were regularly overloaded. People hanging off the side of the cars made for very cool photos but every so often we would be reminded of the foolishness of this practice when someone (usually a tourist) would lose their grip and fall to their death as the tram passed over the Arcos da Lapa.
On 27th August 2011 there was a major crash which led to 6 deaths and 50+ serious injuries. It seems that the crash was caused by a brake failure caused by a substandard repair job – parts of the brakes were being held together with wires instead of using proper screws. The entire Santa Teresa tram system was taken out of commission. This was when the ‘tram teardrop’ image (at the top of the post) was adopted by residents to show their sadness at what had happened and also their unhappiness that the such an important part of Santa Teresa’s identity was missing. One of the reasons for such strong feelings of outrage among residents was that they had been warning of something like this for years.
Since that time there has been a noticeable drop in visitor numbers to Santa Teresa and local businesses have certainly suffered. The authorities announced that 14 new trams would be created and the tracks would be completely overhauled. The date for completion was set to be March 2014. In May it was announced that due to slow progress with the track work, the deadline was being pushed back to June, but this was quickly pushed further back to November.
At the time of writing, just 2 of the 14 trams have been delivered. Testing (using sand bags in place of passengers) has only just begun and the latest I heard was that things won’t be fully up and running until December 2015! The good news is that the new trams look pretty good (the design was approved by Iphan and Inepac – organisations concerned with cultural heritage) and we are told that all safety issues have been addressed.
But seriously, December 2015? What are we going to do in the meantime? Well, it seems a bloke called Tomáš Moravec in Bratislava has come up with a temporary solution (at least for the downhill sections!):







I fear that if people adopt such a solution it will only accelerate the darwinistic thinning of the population of Rio. The same people who are surprised when a bus sneaks up on them in a BRT lane would wonder why the cars didn’t give way to them when they are clearly “a tram” and therefore have the right of way . . . .
Heh heh – it would take a certain type of person to attempt it in Santa Teresa wouldn’t it? Masochists going up and Suicidalists going down! ;)
He didn’t have any downhill! A brake might be useful in Sta Teresa – but not as much fun
Ha ha! Yeah, I think Bratislava looks more suited to this approach than Rio doesn’t it? Given the number of people willing to throw themselves off mountains and out of planes, I’m actually quite surprised no one has tried this yet…
The tram in the pic has TTRANS engraved on a license plate. Did they hire the same company that delivered the previous dodgy trams, according to the post, to build the new ones?
Hey Gritty – you’re right. I was staggered to discover that the original company was still being used. I dread to think about all the murky under-the-table deals and kick-backs that have almost certainly been going on in the background. I can’t see why else they would be using the same company that apparently didn’t have a clue what they were doing just a few short years ago. And now we should trust them?
I did some research (always good to see what the company has to.say). The piece linked below gives both sides a say. I think it is possible that TTRANS has valid points, but they should have aborted the project upon noticing that the city would not take their complaints concerning the rails seriously.
http://veja.abril.com.br/noticia/brasil/bondes-que-o-governo-do-rio-quer-comprar-vao-custar-5-vezes-mais
Great link Gritty – that certainly fills in some of the blanks about this whole affair. Seems to me that the buck stops with ‘Central’ and sounds like they did quite a lot of squirming to shift the blame onto TTrans. As you say, I’m not convinced that TTrans are blameless here, but surely the ultimate fault lies with the company responsible for administering the whole system (including the tracks and commissioning of new trains)?
Off topic: this is pretty cool (check out 19). An awesome Santos jersey on there as well.
http://www.shortlist.com/style/wardrobe/40-coolest-football-kits-ever#gallery-40
Cool! Never seen that Santos shirt with the panda. Other highlights must be the Kaiser Chiefs shirt and the Shrewsbury Town monstrosity (#39).